8. Punishment and War
![Foundations of Libertarian Ethics](https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_4_3_650w/s3/static-page/img/Foundations%20of%20Libertarian%20Ethics_Long_20140923.jpg.webp?itok=0BRjENAm 650w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_4_3_870w/s3/static-page/img/Foundations%20of%20Libertarian%20Ethics_Long_20140923.jpg.webp?itok=7YUrphDn 870w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_4_3_1090w/s3/static-page/img/Foundations%20of%20Libertarian%20Ethics_Long_20140923.jpg.webp?itok=D3OXzQ0E 1090w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_4_3_1310w/s3/static-page/img/Foundations%20of%20Libertarian%20Ethics_Long_20140923.jpg.webp?itok=K6nGEhSm 1310w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_4_3_1530w/s3/static-page/img/Foundations%20of%20Libertarian%20Ethics_Long_20140923.jpg.webp?itok=TTn8YUcD 1530w)
When can you respond to force? The four response positions range from “never” to “impose by force some further penalty on them”. A person’s capacity must be considered. Compensation instead of punishment is generally a libertarian society’s choice.
Threatening to do something is not the same as doing it, but one cannot threaten violence against the innocent.
For the most part, welfare recipients are not rights violators.
The eighth of ten lectures from the Foundations of Libertarian Ethics seminar with Roderick T. Long.