Mises Wire

Delayed Gratification, High Time Preference, Property Rights, and Their Impacts on Culture

Delayed gratification

An individual’s ability to delay gratification has long been understood to be a key predictor for success in many aspects of life (famously underscored by the Marshmallow test). Those who can refrain from consuming all they have, defer consumption, and save for the longer term, tend to have better life outcomes than those who can’t or won’t. So it is with individuals and so it is with cultures and societies.

Those who cannot delay gratification (or cannot delay it much) are said to have a high time preference (“HTP”) and this describes the preferences of a person who values immediate rewards and present consumption much more than future rewards. This focus on short-term gratification de-emphasizes long-term planning, saving, or investing. The foundational cornerstones of building a prosperous society, with rising standards of living, are undermined by consistent HTP behaviors.

The HTP of Irish immigrants to the US have been noted previously. What might not be generally understood is the fact that there were two distinct “Irish” populations who moved to the New World at different times and their HTP had different cultural drivers born of each’s different histories.

Thomas Sowell wrote about the spillover from “Scots-Irish”/“Redneck” culture into African-American “Ghetto” culture. The “Scots-Irish” population (as identified in US parlance) were, a largely Protestant group of people who—having moved from the conflict-ridden Lowlands region of Scotland and settled in Ireland as part of the Ulster Plantations—subsequently migrated to the New World and predominantly settled in what is now Pennsylvania, Appalachia, and the southern United States.

Neither the move into Ireland nor the subsequent move to the New World were peaceful—existing populations tend not to welcome their supplanters. Consequently, the backdrop to these migrations were conflict, turmoil, and instability. The lack of stability resulted in this culture valuing some traits while deprioritizing others and producing an environment where saving and long-term planning were de-emphasized at the expense of more immediate concerns. As a result, the culture developed HTP, on average.

Sowell proposed that, among other short-term behaviors prevalent in this “Redneck” culture, HTP migrated from Scots-Irish culture to African-American culture, for a variety of reasons, including proximity. 

The current piece does not address the HTP of that group of Scots-Irish immigrants to the US but rather deals with the HTP evidenced by the wave of largely Catholic immigrants of the mid to late 19th century.

Consider what happens:

  • When Catholics are forbidden, by the law of the state, from owning/controlling land (either as a freeholder or a leaseholder for periods longer than 31 years);
  • Where Catholics are dispossessed of their property, by the law of the state; 
  • When Catholics are prohibited, by the law of the state, from teaching in Ireland and cannot travel abroad without a license (to prevent Catholics receiving Catholic education overseas);
  • When a Catholic is barred, by the law of the state, from owning a horse worth more than £5 and must sell it to a Protestant, who offers £5 for the Catholic’s horse;
  • When a Catholic is required, by the law of the state, to subdivide property (on succession) equally amongst your heirs (unless the eldest of whom converts to Protestantism and can receive the full estate);
  • When a Catholic tenant, who improves their landlord’s land, would not be compensated for making said improvements but instead would be charged a higher rent, by the law of the state (Protestant tenants not being subject to such restrictions)

One dispossessed Catholic who fled this repression was Richard Cantillon and thank God he did. Had Cantillon not been in Paris, pursuing his banking and merchant career, Essai sur la nature du commerce en general might never have been published, and the intellectual superstructure of economics might have developed much later or much differently.

Another terrible consequence of this gavelkind succession was the constant subdivision which resulted in a multitude of small holdings, which were not optimized to efficient agricultural production. Gavelkind, especially paired with the other restrictions above, resulted in under-investment, lack of mechanization, and poverty. Further it resulted in a scenario where only one crop could possibly sustain a family on the resulting plots—the potato. This is a key reason why the potato monoculture arose in Ireland, with devastating results in the Great Famine of the 1840’s.

Each and every one of these prohibitions/restrictions (a mere sample of the full set of such restrictions in the collection of legislation—collectively known as the Penal Laws) the state enacted to oppress Catholics. Additionally, it resulted in the Catholic majority in Ireland facing a legal environment where saving/investing (instead of consumption) was not a rational response, given the tenuous “property rights” that that majority “enjoyed.” Why build for the future when it is almost certain the benefits of your work, saving, planning and investing will not accrue to you or your heirs?

A further, unfortunate, consequence of a population having a HTP (or of the laws applied to them promoting such preferences) is the predilection towards politics that this engenders. If the law has hindered you in growing the resources available to you, your focus shifts to controlling the distribution of the existing resources. You think not in terms of how you can work, save, and invest for the future but how you can get into a position now to advance your position, consuming resources that preexist. It is worth remembering, in this context, that the political power of the Irish population in the US developed long before that population’s socioeconomic ascendance. In fact, it probably can be said that the general population in Ireland still has an unhealthy habit of looking to politics and the state whenever a problem—usually the result of the state’s interventions—needs to be solved.

Ireland is not alone in this habit, of course, but it is deeply entrenched owing to the culture (shaped by the above history). Perhaps the epitome of a HTP culture were the social welfare payments to families specifically for the purchase of clothing for First Holy Communions and Confirmations. Taxpayer funds provided so families could spend large sums on clothes (bought to impress) that would in all likelihood only be worn once! Only the crisis which followed Ireland’s horrendous fiscal mismanagement during the 2000’s ended this entitlement.

A few hundred years of being legally or effectively barred from husbanding resources, saving for the future, accumulating capital, and increasing productive capacity produces a population which does not particularly value those vital attributes, but does value what it can get right now, through other means. This is unfortunate because elevating standards of living flows from precisely the long-term build up of capital and productive capacity.

However, when the legal shackles are removed, often the cultural or mental shackles persist and remain. This is not just confined to the Irish experience. We see similar effects in South Africa (under apartheid) Russia (under the Tsars and the Communists), and the Jim Crow era in the US South. Populations which are disarmed by and discriminated against by the force of an oppressive state adapt culturally to such circumstances. It takes time for culture to change and, often, culture is remarkably resistant to change, even after the circumstances which gave rise to the culture no longer exist.

I believe that this stems largely from a reactive defensiveness, especially when such change is cast as “selling out to” or imitating aspects of behaviors associated with—in the eyes of the HTP culture—an erstwhile oppressor. So, in Ireland we still see landlords vilified for the “crime” of investing in rental property to this day and vestiges of this anti-landlordism survive in the difficulty of evicting a tenant who doesn’t pay rent. A chief proponent of this anti-landlordism (and spokesperson for housing of a major left-wing party in Ireland) retweeted a version of a painting depicting a 19th century eviction—reworked to feature current day Irish Gardai Siochana (police). The police had recently supported the enforcement of a High Court Order, evicting “activists” who had illegally seized a vacant building.

This is not to say all members of a HTP population exhibit the same behaviors/preferences. Individuals who value production, frugality, and savings and who have a long-term focus are present in all populations, but the more a population tends towards HTP, the less likely that population is to be prosperous.

HTP behaviors in a culture are detrimental to that culture’s long-term prosperity. The historical roots of the HTP vary by culture, but fundamentally, one key reason is the uncertainty of private property rights. We must always be on guard against such actors (state or otherwise), fight against their designs, and educate the young on the virtues of planning, thrift, hard work, saving, and investment.

image/svg+xml
Image Source: Adobe Stock
Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.
What is the Mises Institute?

The Mises Institute is a non-profit organization that exists to promote teaching and research in the Austrian School of economics, individual freedom, honest history, and international peace, in the tradition of Ludwig von Mises and Murray N. Rothbard. 

Non-political, non-partisan, and non-PC, we advocate a radical shift in the intellectual climate, away from statism and toward a private property order. We believe that our foundational ideas are of permanent value, and oppose all efforts at compromise, sellout, and amalgamation of these ideas with fashionable political, cultural, and social doctrines inimical to their spirit.

Become a Member
Mises Institute