Mises Wire

Awakening to Revolution: The Grand Design

Canterbury Cathedral

Following the Great Awakening and the French and Indian War (1754–1763), the British Parliament and civil and ecclesiastical elites renewed attempts to establish an American episcopate of Anglican bishops, which became one of the contributing causes of the American Revolution. Historically, with the state came the church, and with the church came the state. To many Americans, the expansion of the Church of England in America via an Anglican episcopate implied an expanded role for the British imperial state in America; conversely, an expansion of parliamentary political control implied a corresponding expansion of the Church of England as the state-established church in America.

The religious-political issue here was described in a previous article. To put it briefly, the concern was not necessarily opposition to Anglican theology or even to Anglican bishops as such, but rather the possibility that Parliament—claiming the authority to tax the colonies—could also use that authority to establish and finance the Church of England throughout America, impose bishops, dioceses, religious tests, and compulsory tithes, and even suppress competing churches. Thus, the controversy over religious establishment became inseparable from the broader question of parliamentary supremacy and the protection of religious liberty.

In “The Role of Religion in the American Revolution,” Michael W. McConnell expresses something of the failure of the British political elites to fully appreciate the Americans’ civil and religious concerns,

It was a puzzle to the British, and even to some extent many modern historians, why the North American colonists were willing to risk so much—“their lives, their fortunes, and their sacred honor”—for the cause of independence, when their grievances seemed so trifling. The Americans, after all, were probably the freest people on the planet: their taxes were lower than those of their compatriots in the motherland, they were governed in most respects by legislatures of their own choosing, and they enjoyed greater freedom of speech and religion than their compatriots at home.

Now, the impact of the taxes and regulations upon the Americans, while often minimized—not to mention the constitutional controversies involved—was more impactful than is often acknowledged. That said, the oft-neglected aspect of religion in the American Revolution helps more fully explain the religious fervor many Americans had in their opposition to the British state.

In a fairly recent book on the American Revolution, Justifying Revolution: The Early American Clergy and Political Resistance (2021), Gary L. Steward provides a chapter on this topic entitled, “‘No Bishop, No Tyrant!’: The Debate over American Bishops and the Threat to Religious Liberty.” The abstract for the chapter explains the connection between religion and politics in the American Revolution,

This chapter discusses the apprehensions many American clergy felt over the issues of religious liberty on the eve of the American Revolution. The clergy in America were concerned about a rising political absolutism in England that threatened both their civil and religious liberties, and concern over religious issues played a significant role in the final break between the colonies and Great Britain. The plans to impose Episcopal bishops upon the colonies generated great concern, even as the British Parliament adopted an increasingly absolutist posture toward the colonies. The fear of a rising Roman Catholic presence in North America also put the colonies and clergymen on edge, provoking further calls for resistance and vigilance against these growing religious threats. (emphasis added)

Regarding the relevant history, Rothbard succinctly summarizes the process of this movement,

During the first half of the eighteenth century, there were sporadic schemes to impose Anglican bishops upon the American colonies. The schemes had been bitterly resented by all the non-Anglicans in America, and even opposed by most of the Anglicans themselves, who were generally low church and happy to be governing themselves free of English control. The schemes had died down during the war with France, but even then Bishop Thomas Seeker, who had assumed the post of archbishop of Canterbury in 1758, quietly laid plans to revive the scheme as soon as the war was over. His installment was the occasion for the Reverend Samuel Johnson of New York, a long-time advocate of an American episcopate, to join with a group of Anglican ministers in New York and New Jersey to petition for this innovation. Seeker replied with the assurance that he had long had at heart the idea of American bishops. He added that the matter must remain in abeyance, but that the powerful Lord Halifax, president of the Board of Trade, was enthusiastic over the scheme.

Following the French and Indian War (1754–1763), Thomas Secker, the Archbishop of Canterbury, believed the time was right “for pushing the project for American bishops.” This campaign accompanied the overall Grand Design of the British state—seeking imperial assumption of power over the colonies.

The fears and rumors of many Americans concerning an Anglican episcopate provoked opposition from various figures, such as Reverend Jonathan Mayhew. Interestingly, Mayhew was more theologically liberal than the evangelical revivalists, and thus more respected by Rothbard. Yet the challenge to established ecclesiastical authority, especially British ecclesiastical authority, arose not merely from theological liberalism and Enlightenment rationalism, but also from fervent evangelical Protestantism. Though their theological premises differed profoundly, both currents contributed to the erosion of ecclesiastical privilege and the growing resistance to imperial authority.

For example, in 1763, Jonathan Mayhew—provoked by an Anglican minister’s spirited defense of the Anglican Society for Preservation of the Gospel (SPG) in America—thundered against what he saw to be the threat of an Anglican episcopacy in America in his Observations on the Charter and Conduct of the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in Foreign Parts. Note the concern that Mayhew identified and one can see why this concern animated so many Americans (pp. 155–156):

. . .the church of England might become the established religion here; tests be ordained, as in England, to exclude all but conformists from posts of honor and emolument; and all of us be taxed for the support of bishops and their underlings: . . . Will they never let us rest in peace, except where all the weary are at rest? Is it not enough, that they persecuted us out of the old world? Will they pursue us into the new to convert us here?

Therefore, Mayhew recognized—along with many Americans—that with the church came the state and with the state came the church. The Church of England could be used to increase the power of the state of England, and the state of England likewise could be used to increase the power of the Church of England. If the Church of England became the established church in America, and if Parliament could tax Americans without representation, it followed that Americans could be taxed to support the state church. For many Americans, this would have essentially meant funding the state church to restrict and persecute them on the basis of religion, which is one reason why many religious dissenters left England for America in the first place. Along with many other historical factors, the history of the church-state relationship and of religious dissent, both in England and America, especially when combined with the indirect challenge of religious establishments from the Great Awakening, created an ideological environment conducive to religious and political resistance.

Rothbard recognized this religious-political issue as key in the movement toward American independence and the Revolution. He wrote, “Jonathan Mayhew’s pamphlets in 1763 and 1764 on the Anglican question had a profound effect in rallying colonial opposition to an episcopal scheme and in sowing distrust of and hostility to English imperial projects.” This chronology is significant. Standard accounts of the origins of the American Revolution commonly emphasize the imperial crisis following the French and Indian War (1754–1763), particularly the Sugar Act (1764), Stamp Act (1765), and subsequent parliamentary taxation. Yet the controversy over an American Anglican episcopate had already intensified in 1763, before these major taxation measures. The question of parliamentary supremacy, therefore, was not merely an economic or political question that later acquired religious implications. For many American Protestants (as well as Catholics), the prospect of an Anglican establishment imposed and financed by Parliament was itself a threat to their religious liberty. The controversy over bishops thus anticipated and reinforced the constitutional disputes that would soon dominate colonial resistance to British authority.

No less a figure than John Adams recognized the centrality of this issue in the American Revolution. Reflecting retrospectively in a few letters, Adams explained how religion and religious establishment played its part in the struggle. To Jedidiah Morse on December 2, 1815, John Adams wrote,

. . .the apprehension of Episcopacy, contributed 50 years ago, as much as any other cause, to arouse the attention, not only of the enquiring mind but of the common people. . . And urge them to close thinking on the Constitutional Authority of Parliament over the Colonies. . . This nevertheless, was a fact, as certain as any in the history of North America. (emphasis added)

He further specified the nature of the objection many Americans had,

The object[ion] was not merely to the office of a Bishop though even that was dreaded, as to the Authority of Parliament, on which it must be founded. The reasoning was this. the Archbishops, and Bishops in England, can neither locate & limit Dioceses in America, nor ordain Bishops in any part of the dominions of Great Britain, out of the realm. . . There is no power or pretended power, less than Parliament, that can create Bishops in America. But if Parliament can erect Diocesses [sic] & appoint Bishops, they may introduce the whole Hierarchy, establish Tithes, forbid marriages & funerals, establish religions, forbid Dissenters, make Schism Heresy, impose penalties, extending to life and limb, as well as to liberty & property. . . (emphasis added)

Adams further articulated the mindset and logic of Americans here,

All sensible men knew, that this system could not be effected, but by act of Parliament. And if Parliament could do this, they could do all things; and what security could Americans have, for life, Liberty, property or religion? (emphasis added)

Adams also spoke to the scope of this issue and how Parliament’s recognition of Roman Catholicism in Quebec through the Quebec Act of 1774 set a foreboding precedent in the minds of many American colonists:

The Controversy soon interested all men, spread through America, & in Europe, brought forward the aged Dr Johnson, & at last the Arch Bishop of Canterbury. All denominations in America became interested in it, & began to think of the secret latent principle, upon which all encroachments upon us, must be founded, the power of parliament. The Nature and extent of the Authority of Parliament, over the colonies, was discussed every where, till it was discovered, that it had none at all; a conclusion, still more forcibly impressed upon the people by the Canada bill, by which the Roman Catholic religion, & Popish Bishops, were established in that province by authority of a British Parliament. The people said, if Parliament can do this in Canada, they can do the same in all the other Colonies; & they began to see, & freely say, that Parliament had no authority over them, in any case whatsoever. (emphasis added)

Thus, the religious controversy helped lead Americans to question the nature and extent of Parliament’s authority over them, ultimately contributing to the conclusion that Parliament possessed neither the jurisdiction to impose an established church nor the authority to tax them. This controversy preceded, but was not separate from, the political controversies over taxation and regulation.

In another 1818 letter, Adams stated the following, which will serve as the conclusion of this article,

If any gentleman supposes this [religious] controversy to be nothing to the present purpose, he is grossly mistaken. It spread a universal alarm against the authority of Parliament. It excited a general and just apprehension that bishops and dioceses and churches and priests and tithes were to be imposed upon us by Parliament. It was known that neither king, nor ministry, nor archbishops could appoint bishops in America without an act of Parliament; and if Parliament could tax us they could establish the Church of England with all its creeds, articles, tests, ceremonies, and tithes, and prohibit all other churches as conventicles and schism shops. (emphasis added)

image/svg+xml
Image Source: Adobe Stock
Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.
What is the Mises Institute?

The Mises Institute is a non-profit organization that exists to promote teaching and research in the Austrian School of economics, individual freedom, honest history, and international peace, in the tradition of Ludwig von Mises and Murray N. Rothbard. 

Non-political, non-partisan, and non-PC, we advocate a radical shift in the intellectual climate, away from statism and toward a private property order. We believe that our foundational ideas are of permanent value, and oppose all efforts at compromise, sellout, and amalgamation of these ideas with fashionable political, cultural, and social doctrines inimical to their spirit.

Become a Member
Mises Institute