Migration is the ideal political tool. In sufficient numbers, it creates the ideal conditions to ignite strong emotions. For the Left, it allows both virtual-signaling to attain that mythical superior morality they claim to possess while fulfilling the international aspirations of Marxists. Those who disagree are deemed racists.
For the Right, it is the ideal boogie man. Immigration gets blamed for everything, from infrastructure issues, crowding of public services, job competition, and social disorder. Anyone who thinks differently is branded a traitor.
The truth is migration “crises” keep happening in the West, and do create great friction, but if we want to attempt to deal with the issue we need to rightly understand it.
Private Migration
Humans act purposely to improve their situation. We deduce this axiom from the nature of humans. To say that migrants want to improve their life tells us nothing as we can see that from their actions. What we need to know is what the purpose of their actions is specifically and how they intend to bring it about.
Migration has been part of the human experience since the dawn of man. Natural—or what I want to call “private”—migration consists of someone intending to settle in a foreign community by integrating within it. We need to understand that human communities are formed when humans coordinate themselves and work together.
Contrary to popular belief, this is done through voluntary exchange, as this is the only way to value things and allow economic calculation. Without that, coordination and production is impossible. This means that whoever wants to integrate into a community needs to do so through voluntary exchange.
This is what naturally immigrants will do. When I emigrated from Spain into the UK, I did so with the intention of getting a job and producing something that the local population wanted so I could engage in voluntary exchange to get what I wanted to sustain myself. This migration has to be beneficial both for the immigrant and the local population or else it would not happen. Locals can easily repel these newcomers by refusing to exchange with them.
Humanitarian and Ecological Migration
We tend to see large movements of people as a result of some conflict. The EU talks about humanitarian and ecological migrants but this is simply a lie. Conflicts and natural disasters displace people, but these are not migrants. They have no intention of settling anywhere else. They are escaping real and imminent danger and are thus in survival mode. Once the danger has passed, they will return home.
They are displaced, not migrating. Of course, a community should help them, but help them to do what they want to do, which is return to their home. There are, however. other migrants.
Political Migration
These are the ones who illegally cross the borders in large waves. Their intention is not to integrate with the community, quite the contrary. Their intention is to be taken in by the authorities and be sustained with public resources, in some cases indefinitely.
The local population understandably will see them as an unproductive drain on the community. Authorities worsen the conflict by keeping them unproductive by preventing them from working, and by tolerating behavior that would never be tolerated of the local population, such as settling in a public beach.
The sad truth is that authorities attract these immigrants and sustain them once they are here because there are strong political incentives to do so. Right-wing politicians have gained power on a promise of a closed borders policy, whereas Leftists have gained power in other areas due to the direct vote of immigrants.
Crucially, they keep the local population squabbling about open or closed borders instead of real issues. Is this the debate we should be having?
Ceuta
At the end of July of this year, tens of thousands forced their way across the border between Morocco and Ceuta—a Spanish city in North Africa. This “migration crisis” has a few interesting differences from other cases that expose what I have said above.
When this wave of immigrants arrived in the city (some estimates say there were more newcomers than local population), locals responded with a non-violent policy: they just closed shop.
This exposed the newcomers. They had come with nothing, which political migrants do so authorities are “forced” to take them in immediately. But the wave was so big that no one took them in. Most of the newcomers turned around and left. They were not humanitarian migrants. They were not escaping real and imminent danger or they would have stayed. They did not come from a war-torn country. They had expected to live off public resources. Absent these, they had to return home, which they had no problem doing.
The local response was very effective but was sabotaged. Ceuta also exposed the intentions of authorities. The belief is that governments fight illegal immigration but the truth is the opposite. In Ceuta, as soon as they saw the newcomers leaving, they scrambled to intervene, managing to provide sustenance to a few thousand and keep them in the city. The grand plan of the government since has been to “process” them by taking them into mainland Spain.
Absent government and ONGs, newcomers in Ceuta would have all gone back home, a short walk from Ceuta for many of them. But there are strong political incentives both to have illegal immigration and “migration crises,” and to disrupt any private solution to these issues.
Another myth dispelled is that political migration can happen without disruption. This could only happen if newcomers were treated in the same way as the local population. But authorities are always trying not to appear “racists” and so allow behaviors of the newcomers that they would never allow of locals. There is a funny clip on the internet comparing the treatment of elderly locals in Benidorm beach, where they get harassed by local police for installing a parasol on the beach “too early,” against the treatment of Moroccans in Ceuta at the Trampolin beach, where they were allowed to live for two months.
The situation has become even more dystopic in the last few hours. After two months of settlement in the Ceuta beaches, as part of the political campaign for the upcoming elections, the government has rounded up all the newcomers and cleared the beaches in 48 hours. Even worse, more than a thousand illegals have returned voluntarily to Morocco. Government wanted them there while they were useful, but when moving them meant more votes, the newcomers were swiftly dealt with.
Conclusion
Private immigration responds to a real demand from the local population. They are ultimately the ones that decide if a newcomer will succeed and stay or will go back.
Newcomers go from low-demand areas to high-demand ones, thus reducing consumer prices and allowing more production where they settle. They bring new ideas and spur competition, making the local economy more resilient and dynamic, improving everyone’s quality of life.
Private migration depends on voluntary exchange so will only happen if all parties benefit. Political migration, on the contrary, responds to incentives created by those in power who need them to increase power and use it as a political weapon against their opposition.
Political migration depends on the authorities extracting resources from the local population so that they can consume them. It is a drain on the local economy and creates conflict.
If all land were private, things would be more straightforward. Newcomers would be either guests or trespassers. But even in our highly interventionist world, local populations can do a lot to expose what the elites are doing.
We should coin a term for political immigrants, both to expose the political incentives that cause this migration and to recognize why they are different from private migrants. Governments cause these crises because they benefit from them. It is time we stopped the open-versus-closed borders debate and instead debated government intervention versus no intervention.