Mises Wire

Elon Musk Didn’t Cause the Recent FAA Meltdown. Government Did

FAA

Whenever there is an air disaster in this country or problems with airports or air traffic control, both Republicans and Democrats rush to the microphones to claim that someone from the opposing political party is responsible. And, as if on cue, someone on the other side claims the accuser is practicing “cheap politics” (which really is what the accuser is doing).

The recent meltdown in the Federal Aviation Administration’s ATC system, following an attempt to switch from copper wire to fiber optics to upgrade a router in Arkansas. What was seemingly a small and supposedly benign operation turned into a disaster, which says much about the system if this is all it takes to send it crashing down. Furthermore, the fact that much of the ATC system depends upon copper wire instead of fiber optics is one more example of a government-run entity operating in a time warp, something that is common among socialist systems.

As Connor O’Keeffe has noted, the results of this system breakdown were costly to the airline industry and the travelers it serves:

. . .the agency (FAA) ordered every departing aircraft in the country to stay on the ground and landed roughly 3,500 planes that were already in the air. This nationwide ground stop would continue for over four hours as officials searched for the source of the problem—making it the longest shutdown of American airspace since 9/11.

Naturally, the Democratic members of Congress immediately claimed that the Trump administration’s culling of FAA employees more than a year ago caused the trouble:

U.S. Rep. Jim Himes (D-CT-4) is blaming Elon Musk’s cuts to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) for Friday’s nationwide ground stop and ongoing airport delays.

The article continues:

Himes, appearing on Face the Nation with Margaret Brennen, said money isn’t the full issue.

“You remember when Elon Musk was standing on a stage spinning his chainsaw around, cutting government willy-nilly,” Himes said. “Well, part of that chainsaw got 1,300 employees of the FAA to resign or to retire. They fired 400 probationary employees. These are the technical specialists and the maintenance people.”

Like most members of Congress when they open their mouths, Himes was speaking in ignorance. However, as O’Keefe pointed out, ignorance is not limited to the Democratic party or to members of Congress. Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy also has been competing with his critics to see who can jump into a sea of irrelevance:

Transport Secretary Sean Duffy opened with the most predictable and clichéd talking point. Before the cause was even known with certainty, he went in front of reporters Friday night and portrayed the entire episode as proof that his department needed more money.

He blamed Congress for refusing to force taxpayers to fork over even more to help modernize the antiquated hardware and software the national Air Traffic Control system relies on. Somewhat ironically, the work that appears to have caused the network failure was the exact kind of hardware upgrade the current administration is demanding more of. It happened one day after the DOT requested $30.1 billion but somehow proved to Duffy that more was needed. He said he now wanted $50 billion, without explaining where that extra money would go.

As other writers and I have pointed out on this page, the problems of the FAA are economic or, to be more specific, they are problems involving economic calculation, which has always plagued socialist systems, which must substitute political calculation into the accounting mix. Because socialist entities do not acknowledge profits and losses, there is no way that producers can place anything approximating economically accurate value on its factors of production, including labor and capital. Writes O’Keefe:

As Mises explained brilliantly in his book Bureaucracy, because government immunizes itself from economic losses, it cannot conduct economic calculation like everyone operating within a market does. By economic calculation, Mises meant the allocation of scarce resources towards whatever uses best meet the wants and needs of the end user, and the constant refinement and search for even more valuable ventures spurred on by the profit-and-loss incentive.

This point is vital to understanding why the FAA is in perpetual crisis with air traffic control. According to politicians and the media, the problem to be solved is one of inadequate technology, so it is up to Congress to appropriate enough money to the FAA so it can purchase the “right kind” of equipment and properly staff its air traffic control towers and other facilities. Thus, “solving” the problem is simply one of Congress displaying the proper political will.

Yet even though the ATC system is woefully undercapitalized and the work environment for air traffic controllers and their support staff can be toxic, the government-led “solution” is no solution at all; it is the problem. No matter how much money Congress sets aside for the ATC system, it always will be in crisis. Given the inherent dangers with air travel, perhaps we should be thankful that we do not have more aviation accidents than we have had in recent years.

But why can’t a government-run administrative system identify both the problems and solutions? The first answer is that if government is the cause of the problem, one doubts that it also could provide a solution, especially given the penchant of government agents and politicians to blame anyone and anything else. The second is that the process of finding the best “solution” and assigning the tools needed to do the job cannot be done through top-down central planning.

Keep in mind that when Congress appropriates money, it does so with specific actions in mind, which means that the FAA would be expected to build a centrally-planned ATC system with defined technologies and directed by Congress. That means using contractors and suppliers tied to various members of Congress connected to these firms—and their lobbyists. As O’Keeffe has written, we have been down this road before, beginning in 1981:

. . .throughout these forty-five years of “modernizing” the ATC, the money we’re told was required to complete it has kept going up. The asks went from $12 billion in 1981, to $51 billion by 2003, to another $36 billion for NextGen, with around $5 billion in supplemental modernization funding under Obama and Biden. Each new plan promised a modern air traffic control system within a decade or two, and none of them delivered it. And that is despite the fact that Congress has given the FAA over $100 billion in that same time period for these modernization efforts.

As one can see, this is a never-ending scam in which the public is told that this modernization effort will work this time, as long as Congress delivers the tax dollars to the system. Likewise, Sen. Tammy Duckworth of Illinois has introduced a bill calling for the Pentagon to “modernize” its ATC system, which also is a dysfunctional patchwork quilt that supposedly can be “fixed” if only Congress appropriates a little more money.

The only analogy that seems to properly describe this charade is that of the band in the movie, “Animal House,” trying to march through a wall. Lest one be fooled by the efforts by Congress and (of course) the contractors and suppliers eagerly awaiting their next money dump, it is clear that we are looking at yet another example of what Joshua Mawhorter and Connor O’Keeffe have called “interventionist non-intervention” in which, “. . .the state—following coercive taxation and monopolization or competition suppression—can intervene through doing ‘nothing,’ that is, paid non-delivery of promised and monopolized service.”

The “modern”—if we can call it that—US ATC system is one in which the FAA is answerable to no one whenever it fails. We know the drill: a disaster or near-miss (there are many of those) occurs and either the Secretary of Transportation or the head of the FAA is brought before a congressional committee in which members of the opposition party demand to know how the FAA will “fix” the problem (while at the same time insisting that those in charge are idiots), with congressional members of the appointee’s political party trying to defend whoever is in the dock.

This is a wash-rinse-repeat exercise that provides political theater but little else. As we have noted before on this page, there is a way out—permitting private enterprise to direct and run air traffic control. As Ludwig von Mises wrote more than 80 years ago, government entities cannot engage in the necessary economic calculation that would provide the direction needed for entrepreneurs to create and build entities like an ATC system that would be safe, reliable, and up-to-date.

These are words that will go unheeded because no one in Washington wants to let go of their authority, even if that means the government is endangering the lives of everyone who flies in a passenger or cargo plane. Instead, like that poor student in “Animal House,” the authorities will insist that “all is well,” and that the next congressional appropriation will finally fix the problems.

image/svg+xml
Image Source: Adobe Stock - Chad Robertson - stock.adobe.com
Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.
What is the Mises Institute?

The Mises Institute is a non-profit organization that exists to promote teaching and research in the Austrian School of economics, individual freedom, honest history, and international peace, in the tradition of Ludwig von Mises and Murray N. Rothbard. 

Non-political, non-partisan, and non-PC, we advocate a radical shift in the intellectual climate, away from statism and toward a private property order. We believe that our foundational ideas are of permanent value, and oppose all efforts at compromise, sellout, and amalgamation of these ideas with fashionable political, cultural, and social doctrines inimical to their spirit.

Become a Member
Mises Institute