JLS: The Background, Failure, and Aftermath of Nozick’s Attempt to Justify the State
- Read more about JLS: The Background, Failure, and Aftermath of Nozick’s Attempt to Justify the State
Perhaps the most fundamental question in political philosophy is whether any state is justified. The most impressive modern attempt to justify the state is in part 1 of Robert Nozick’s Anarchy, State, and Utopia. Nozick argues that a minimal state, and only a minimal state, is compatible with our having natural rights. Here, I clarify the logic of Nozick’s strategy and show that his attempt to justify the state fails at every step. A central issue is that Nozick implicitly adopts a restricted, rather than absolute or even bounded absolute, conception of natural rights.