Mises Wire

Thomas Paine Defended Liberty, Not Egalitarianism

Thomas Paine

The Wikipedia entry for Thomas Paine’s pamphlet Common Sense describes it as an “egalitarian” tract that called for the equality of all men. The implication is that Paine’s defense of liberty, which inspired the American Revolution, was rooted in egalitarian ideals of racial equality. The message is that the Revolutionaries fought, as Abraham Lincoln later put it in the context of his war against the South, for an amorphous and aspirational notion of racial equality.

As David Gordon has explained, when it is put to Wikipedia-style historians that many of the Founders owned slaves and could scarcely have been fighting a war to promote racial equality, these historians answer that it was an aspirational revolution. We are to believe that the colonists were fighting for the theoretical hope that they might one day become better men and free their slaves.

The citation offered for the egalitarian interpretation of Common Sense is an entry in Encyclopedia Britannica by the American Marxist historian, Philip Foner. Foner was the author of “Life and Writings of Thomas Paine.” Wikipedia’s own entry on Foner describes him as a Marxist thinker:

Philip Sheldon Foner (December 14, 1910 – December 13, 1994) was an American labor historian and teacher. Foner was a prolific author and editor of more than 100 books. He is considered a pioneer in his extensive works on the role of radicals, Black Americans, and women in American labor and political history, which were generally neglected in mainstream academia at the time. A Marxist thinker, he influenced more than a generation of scholars, inspiring some of the work published by younger academics from the 1970s on.

The New York Times also described Foner as “an eminent Marxist labor historian.” Given the reliance on Marxist thinkers to interpret Paine’s life and writings, it is no surprise that Paine is depicted as an egalitarian. The Wikipedia entry on Common Sense states that, “Paine collected moral and political arguments to encourage common people in the Colonies to fight for egalitarian government.” The entry for egalitarianism informs readers that,

Egalitarianism (from French égal ‘equal’; also equalitarianism) is a school of thought within political philosophy that builds on the concept of social equality, prioritizing it for all people.

It is true that Paine expressed strong opinions against slavery, but it does not follow that his political philosophy was about racial equality. The argument that Paine was expressing the political principles later propounded by Lincoln at Gettysburg—the notion that the foundation of America is rooted in egalitarian ideals—certainly fits conveniently alongside Foner’s Marxist ideology. But matters were not that simple. James V. Lynch argues that, “By proclaiming Paine an abolitionist and racial egalitarian, Congress perpetuated his mythical antislavery position. . . Paine’s reputation as an abolitionist developed as a tangled skein of no readings, misreadings, misattributions, and carelessness.” Lynch further explains that,

To be sure, Thomas Paine in no way supported slavery; indeed he found it repulsive and sincerely hoped for its eradication. But so did many late eighteenth-century intellectuals. It might even be argued that Thomas Jefferson, vilified in recent historical literature for his ambivalence about race, tried harder than Paine to challenge chattel slavery. It is a great leap from private thought to public action, especially when that action challenges the racial assumptions and the social and economic foundations of a people and their society.

The determination to depict Paine as an abolitionist is not matched by similar zeal in relation to Thomas Jefferson, as Lynch points out, nor in relation to Robert E. Lee who, in a private letter to his wife, described slavery as a moral and political evil. We rarely hear about the abolitionist societies of Virginia, nor of Virginia’s legislative attempts to abolish slavery.

The strained significance attached to Thomas Paine’s sentiments against slavery—including attributing to him pamphlets of which it is now doubted that he was the author—is out of proportion to other similar examples. Lynch observes that, “When Paine arrived in America in 1774, antislavery thought was not uncommon.” The specific emphasis on Paine as an abolitionist is largely attributable to the broader effort to depict the American Revolution as an egalitarian revolution.

Murray Rothbard’s book Conceived in Liberty put this history in a different light. Rothbard did not reject the notion that men are inspired to fight for ideals, but he identified the relevant ideal as that of liberty rooted in self-ownership and property rights.

In protesting against British taxes, Virginians said nothing about holding egalitarian ideals concerning “all people.” Rather, they “asserted freedom from parliamentary taxation as a right” vested in all British subjects. Rothbard highlighted the example of Richard Henry Lee of Virginia:

He asserted the “unquestionable right” of Americans to “the free possession of property,” and to laws and taxes made by their own representatives. He sensed a design by the mother country to “oppress North America with the iron hand of power, unrestrained by any sentiment, drawn from reason, the liberty of mankind, or the genius of their own government. Finally, he warned that “possibly this step of the mother country, though intended to oppress and keep us low, in order to secure our dependence, may be subversive of this end. Poverty and oppression, among those whose minds are filled with ideas of British liberty, . . . may produce a fatal resentment of parental care being converted into tyrannical usurpation.”

Similarly, South Carolina “[opposed] any parliamentary tax as violating the ‘inherent right of every British subject not to be taxed but by his own consent or that of his representative.’”

Here equality meant the equal right of every British subject. Paine rejected status distinctions of king and subject, of lord and serf. He titled this section as an explicit rejection of monarchy and hereditary titles. He used the term “race of men” not in reference to black and white, as Lincoln later did, but in reference to what was then seen as a race of superior people—the King and the hereditary lords who ruled by divine right of birth:

OF MONARCHY AND HEREDITARY SUCCESSION

Mankind being originally equals in the order of creation, the equality could only be destroyed by some subsequent circumstance; the distinctions of rich, and poor, may in a great measure be accounted for, and that without having recourse to the harsh, ill-sounding names of oppression and avarice.

. . . But there is another and greater distinction for which no truly natural or religious reason can be assigned, and that is, the distinction of men into kings and subjects. Male and female are the distinctions of nature, good and bad the distinctions of heaven; but how a race of men came into the world so exalted above the rest, and distinguished like some new species, is worth inquiring into, and whether they are the means of happiness or of misery to mankind.

In the same vein, Paine challenged the authority of kings, exhorting the colonists not to bow to any king:

In the early ages of the world, according to the scripture chronology, there were no kings. . . As the exalting one man so greatly above the rest cannot be justified on the equal rights of nature, so neither can it be defended on the authority of scripture; for the will of the Almighty, as declared by Gideon and the prophet Samuel, expressly disapproves of government by kings.

Paine further explained that the equality of all subjects is essential to peace, and urged the colonists to reject monarchical rule and feudal class distinctions. Perfect equality here meant equality of subjects, not equality of races in the sense that Lincoln later stated. Paine said,

Where there are no distinctions there can be no superiority, perfect equality affords no temptation. The Republics of Europe are all (and we may say always) in peace. Holland and Switzerland are without wars, foreign or domestic: Monarchical governments, it is true, are never long at rest; the crown itself is a temptation to enterprizing ruffians at home; and that degree of pride and insolence ever attendant on regal authority, swells into a rupture with foreign powers, in instances, where a republican government, by being formed on more natural principles, would negotiate the mistake.

Rothbard interpreted Paine’s devotion to liberty as resistance to tyranny, a principle which he also saw reflected in John Locke and other libertarian thinkers. Far from being merely aspirational, the American Revolution was “a true people’s war against British rule.”

image/svg+xml
Image Source: Adobe Stock
Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.
What is the Mises Institute?

The Mises Institute is a non-profit organization that exists to promote teaching and research in the Austrian School of economics, individual freedom, honest history, and international peace, in the tradition of Ludwig von Mises and Murray N. Rothbard. 

Non-political, non-partisan, and non-PC, we advocate a radical shift in the intellectual climate, away from statism and toward a private property order. We believe that our foundational ideas are of permanent value, and oppose all efforts at compromise, sellout, and amalgamation of these ideas with fashionable political, cultural, and social doctrines inimical to their spirit.

Become a Member
Mises Institute