Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics 19, no. 4 (Winter 2016)
ABSTRACT: Machaj (2015) does a great service in pointing out a key assumption, heretofore unaddressed, in Filleule (2007) and Hülsmann (2010). Machaj errs, however, in stating that who saves will have an ambiguous effect on the interest rate and that where savings are directed can have ambiguous effects on the length of production. In this brief comment I will first show that who saves will have no effect on the interest rate. I then turn my attention to what it means to “lengthen” the structure of production. Although extended production time or additional “stages” of production make convenient placeholders for increased roundaboutness, they fail to grasp the core concept as it pertains to capital theory: what is it about production processes that makes more or better consumer goods?
KEYWORDS: capital theory, interest, production structure, roundaboutness, labor intensity
JEL CLASSIFICATION: B13, B53, D24, E43
![](https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_650w/s3/static-page/img/QJAE_20141027_0_0.jpg.webp?itok=EOik_ZU4 650w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_870w/s3/static-page/img/QJAE_20141027_0_0.jpg.webp?itok=Mwx2w2Z3 870w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_1090w/s3/static-page/img/QJAE_20141027_0_0.jpg.webp?itok=Cc3mypqm 1090w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_1310w/s3/static-page/img/QJAE_20141027_0_0.jpg.webp?itok=0zXyHG5H 1310w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_1530w/s3/static-page/img/QJAE_20141027_0_0.jpg.webp?itok=8Oqlt4uY 1530w)
![David Howden](https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_650w/s3/static-page/img/David%20Howden.jpg.webp?itok=nVDBJI1s 650w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_870w/s3/static-page/img/David%20Howden.jpg.webp?itok=VcNHidJc 870w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_1090w/s3/static-page/img/David%20Howden.jpg.webp?itok=aVyikPMD 1090w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_1310w/s3/static-page/img/David%20Howden.jpg.webp?itok=UZ3ACCRb 1310w,https://cdn.mises.org/styles/responsive_6_9_1530w/s3/static-page/img/David%20Howden.jpg.webp?itok=W261aLYX 1530w)
Dr. David Howden is Chair of the Department of Business and Economics, and professor of economics, at Saint Louis University at its Madrid campus. A Fellow of the Mises Institute, he is the author of over 50 scholarly articles and books. His research focuses on the business cycle and fractional-reserve banking.
Howden, David, “The Interest Rate and the Length of Production: A Comment,” Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics 19, no. 4 (Winter 2016): 345–358.