What is Seen and Unseen on the Gulf Coast

It is fitting that the Mises Institute has released the Bastiat Collection on the two-year anniversary of Hurricane Katrina. Though hundreds of years have passed since Frédéric Bastiat, the beauty of sound economic reasoning is that it does not change over time. In particular, his essay, “That Which is Seen, and That Which is Not Seen,” is especially insightful in analyzing the rebuilding of the Gulf Coast. In first expounding his lesson and then applying it to the conflict between the private and public sectors, this article seeks to attack the fallacies of government spending and vindicate the free market. No one questions the need for rebuilding after Katrina, and few would go so far as the imbecilic economist to praise the hurricane, but there is still the question of who is to do the rebuilding. With a virtually unlimited purse, the government’s approach to reconstruction is necessarily wasteful, bureaucratic, and inefficient. As Ludwig von Mises noted, the problem with bureaucracy is that consumer demand is subservient to meaningless rules, edicts, and red tape. Through this lens, it is not difficult to understand the reason behind the inefficiencies of local, state, and federal government agencies.

Does Capitalism Make Us More Materialistic?

There was a time when the advocates of socialism argued that it would lead man to material abundance, whereas free-market capitalism would lead only to increasing misery and would ultimately collapse under its own internal stresses. You don’t hear that too much these days, and for good reason. A century of empirical evidence has shown the contrary—that the free market leads to increasing wealth and material freedom, while socialism leads us only to poverty, state supremacy, and ultimately, mass murder.

Who owns the copyright to cut-up jeans or low-rise pants?

Or better yet, what do the fashion and dining industries have in common?

Neither has traditionally been protected via IP laws.

Yet while conventional wisdom suggests that IP regimes are a necessary condition for both invention and innovation, the fashion and dining industries thrive and expand each year.

At least, that is until the political class has its way. Recently Senator Schumer of New York has proposed legislation that would “extend copyright protection to the fashion industry.”

Don’t Discount the Fed Discount Window

Though many have dismissed the Federal Reserve’s decision to drop the discount rate from 6.25% to 5.75% as mere window dressing, there are reasons to think otherwise. Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America and Wachovia each borrowed $500 million from the Federal Reserve discount window last week. Average end-of-day Fed credit outstanding for the week ending September 5 measured $1.1 billion, the largest balance loaned out via the discount window since September 2001 and the most since the discount window was reformed in 2003. Of interest too are the sorts of collateral the Fed accepts nowadays from banks in return for loans. The list reads like a Who’s Who of the investment world. The regulars turn up: US treasuries, government agency debt, and foreign government debt. But the Fed can accept far more than that.

Antitrust Policy Is Both Harmful and Useless

The United States has had antitrust legislation at the federal and state level for more than 100 years. (The Sherman Antitrust Act [1890] and the Federal Trade Commission Act [1914] are the basic federal statutes.) The laws make illegal “every contract, combination … or conspiracy in restraint of trade” and any attempt to “monopolize” through merger or acquisition; in addition, “unfair … and deceptive practices” are also forbidden. Given this broad regulatory mandate, antitrust law is arguably this nation’s oldest ad hoc “industrial policy.” But whether any of this regulation has ever made economic sense is entirely debatable. Despite the dismal enforcement experience, the antitrust establishment generally still supports vigorous enforcement of the antitrust laws. In antitrust, the more things change the more they seem to stay the same.

A Political Theory of Geeks and Wonks

Lots of people get interested in political ideas through political campaigns. Maybe this is because politics forces you to decide who you are and what you believe. I can vaguely recall when I was very young, perhaps 7 years old, that I discovered that my best friend’s family considered themselves Democratic whereas I was pretty sure that my family was Republican. I asked someone what that meant and only received hazy answers that concerned seemingly big issues about government. I didn’t think much about it but nonetheless, they were my first thoughts on the thing that would consume my life.

So it is for lots of people: politics is the entry way into taking political ideas seriously. If your interest intensifies, you tend to go one of two ways: wonk or geek. These are terms that applies in many categories of life—Wikipedia gives serviceable definitions of both wonk and geek—but the terms take on new meaning in politics.