WALL-E: Economic Ignorance and the War on Modernity

The Disney-Pixar film WALL-E is an assault on modern civilization, borne of deep economic and historical ignorance. First, it makes the Marxian assumption that it would be possible for a single corporation to subsume the entire world. Then the movie shows humanity seeking salvation in abandoning a sustainable automatic food production system - which had apparently worked without fail for seven centuries - and suddenly resorting to traditional agriculture. The creators of WALL-E, sitting in their comfortable Hollywood studios, do a tremendous disservice to the civilization that made their work and high standards of living possible.

A Nudge in the Wrong Direction

In Nudge, Thaler and Sunstein try to combine libertarianism and paternalism by arguing that a “nudge” from the state can benefit those nudged, while staying consistent with liberty because it does not force anyone to do anything. Nudge’s argument is far from airtight. But even more devastating is its reliance on a false premise. The “market failure” examples it promises to improve are actually government failures.

Cheeseburgers When Subsidized

Corn, wheat, sugar and a dozen other crops all got increased subsidies in the recent Farm Bill, signed with terrifying agreement. Is there an end in sight? One overlooked clue while those crops are fetching sky-high prices in that other system known as the free market is data showing farms took acreage from pastureland, which livestock need to graze. So, ranchers have been liquidating herds and giving up in the battle against soaring feed costs.

Grand Theft Society

A core problem with government is that its managers believe that all reality will conform to their wishes if they issue the right orders, pass the right laws, and put the right people in charge. Reality resists this simple-minded approach; witness the debacle of the war on terror. Sadly, the same group that has managed that war is now managing another one: the war on recession.

Activity v. Activism

The Supreme Court’s Heller ruling upholding the Second Amendment’s individual right to bear arms has created uproar among liberals. But rather than addressing Justice Scalia’s powerful logical and historical analysis of the amendment, they have attacked it as judicial activism.

However, the central issue is not judicial activism. It is not whether the court should be active, but which principles will inform its activity. In fact, activism that constrains government power in deference to constitutional protections mirrors our founders’ views.