G. Stanley Hall: A Priestly Prophet of a New Dispensation

G. Stanley Hall had been to the mountaintop, he had seen the promised land, he had as it were “achieved another new birth superimposed on that of adolescence.”’ He had achieved a new vision, and thus a new birth, the birth of a “superman.” Hall believed that like Jesus and Buddha before him he was called to preach a new gospel, a new dispensation which would lift “Mansoul” to its next higher stage of evolutionary development. That new dispensation was, for Hall, the “New Psychology” which he helped structure and create.

Public School Movement vs. the Libertarian Tradition

Given the temper of the times it was surprising that following the American Revolution there appeared proposals for national systems of education. The libertarian tradition which fed the flames of the Revolution was staunchly opposed to a union of government and schooling. The greatest fear was that such a union would lead to despotism over the mind and be the enemy of freedom of thought and speech.

Volume 7, Number 1 (1983)

Ayn Rand and the Is-Ought Problem

Although ethical systems may be divided into those which claim to be objective and those which freely acknowledge their own subjectivity, a special place must be reserved for an ethical system such as that of Ayn Rand which takes its name from this central claim to objectivity—Objectivism.

In this essay, the claims of Objectivism to present an objective epistemology will not he considered, but only the claim of Rand’s ethical system to represent an objective value system.

Volume 7, Number 1 (1983)

Private Police: A Note

There are those to whom the question of whether to privatize the nation’s police forces is mere academic whimsy—a question of consequence only to the eggheads and cranks of the Academy, not to those who so solidly inhabit the “real world.” Most of these believe the enforcement of law to be the exclusive province of the state. Such a belief is rooted in an obvious falsehood: the notion that there is a unique and singular commodity called “enforcement of law.” There is, in fact, no such singular commodity.

Volume 14, Number 1 (1999)

In Defense of Natural End Ethics: A Rejoinder to O’Neil and Osterfeld

Patrick M. O’Neil and David Osterfeld have offered some criticisms of our natural end interpretation and defense of Rand’s ethics. This essay is a rejoinder to these criticisms. It consists of two parts: (I)a reply to O’Neil and (II)a reply to Osterfeld. In the case of the latter, we will confine ourselves to commenting only on those statements which constitute criticisms of our position. We will not discuss Osterfeld’s own views regarding the foundation of ethics.

Volume 7, Number 1 (1983)

Land-Use Planning: Implications of the Economic Calculation Debate

The recent widely cited National Agricultural Lands Study (NALS) adds to the growing number of individuals and organizations holding the view that land resources are too important to be left to the “whims of market forces.” In this view, there should be a shift from private ownership of land to social or political control of land use.

Volume 7, Number 1 (1983)

Social Contract as a Basis of Norms: A Critique

In this note I will argue that social contract theories aimed at establishing norms for personal and community life are inadequate. Briefly, I show that in Kant and Rawls the alleged contractual basis for the legitimacy of law and government is supplemented with the very strict requirement of self-consistency of the resulting norms. Once, however, Kant’s and Rawls’s own framework for the social con- tract thesis is abandoned, as it ultimately will have to be for various reasons, what is left is not a social contract but rationality as the basis of norms.

Sociological Theory in the Shadow of Durkheim’s Revolt Against Economics

Over the span of one hundred and fifty years, dissatisfaction with one or more of the fundamental postulates of theoretical economics has given impetus to the development of new “theoretical” sciences. Depending upon one’s viewpoint, scientific socialism, sociology, institutional economics, and so on may represent several such attempts, or they may represent a single multifaceted effort. Whichever the case, the order of procedure in such undertakings is straightforward.