The Trouble With Principle, by Stanley Fish

Consumed by Argument?

Mises Review 6, No. 3 (Fall 2000)

THE TROUBLE WITH PRINCIPLE
Stanley Fish
Harvard University Press, 1999; 328 pgs

 

I expected to dislike this book. Stanley Fish, the author of distinguished books on Milton and George Herbert, long ago found the world of literary scholarship too confining. He obtained a law degree and frequently comments on public affairs, usually from a leftist point of view.

Freud and the Question of Pseudoscience, by Frank Cioffi

Interpreting Freud’s Dreams

Mises Review 6, No. 3 (Fall 2000)

FREUD AND THE QUESTION OF PSEUDOSCIENCE
Frank Cioffi
Open Court, 1998, ix + 313 pgs.
 

The validity of Freud’s theories seems at first sight far removed from the usual concerns of The Mises Review. In fact, it is not. Freud mounted a strong attack on morality and tradition. If, as Freud believed, conscience arises through irrational and bizarre unconscious processes, what grounds have we to pay heed to its dictates?