A Renegade History of the United States

Thaddeus Russell’s A Renegade History of the United States is an important new book: a demonstration that rebels and renegades are society’s benefactors. In this revisionist view of American history, you see, there is “an enduring civil war” between these two factions — the “renegades” and the “moral guardians,” whom he also calls the “disciplinarians.”

Which tendency dominates?

The Democrats are having fun at Republican expense over the alleged GOP mishandling of a bill that would extend the police-state provisions of the Patriot Act. The leadership figured it was a no-brainer. Aren’t we for law enforcement and against crime? The rank-and-file knew better than refused to go along. And the bill went down to defeat What’s going on here is not a “mishandling” but an ideological split between libertarian impulses and authoritarian ones.