Mises Wire

For the FAA, Failure Pays

Tired man and woman are sitting in the waiting room of the international airport

On Friday afternoon, at around 3:30pm Eastern, the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) air traffic communications network was suddenly flooded with data. According to the FAA, around 1,000 connection attempts were hitting its FTI network every 4 to 5 seconds.

The surge in traffic caused nearly the entire network to become unstable, threatening radar feeds and radio links between aircraft and controllers at seventeen of the twenty-two ATC control centers.

In response, the agency ordered every departing aircraft in the country to stay on the ground and landed roughly 3,500 planes that were already in the air. This nationwide ground stop would continue for over four hours as officials searched for the source of the problem—making it the longest shutdown of American airspace since 9/11.

The FAA claims that it traced the flooding back to two sites. The first was a remote radio site in El Dorado, Arkansas, where a contractor had just installed a new router while upgrading an old copper line to fiber. The second was a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, where the same upgrade had been done weeks earlier. Once both sites were blocked, the network stabilized, the ground stop was lifted, and the blame game began.

Transport Secretary Sean Duffy opened with the most predictable and clichéd talking point. Before the cause was even known with certainty, he went in front of reporters Friday night and portrayed the entire episode as proof that his department needed more money.

He blamed Congress for refusing to force taxpayers to fork over even more to help modernize the antiquated hardware and software the national Air Traffic Control system relies on. Somewhat ironically, the work that appears to have caused the network failure was the exact kind of hardware upgrade the current administration is demanding more of. It happened one day after the DOT requested $30.1 billion but somehow proved to Duffy that more was needed. He said he now wanted $50 billion, without explaining where that extra money would go.

The establishment media tried to portray Duffy’s demand as yet another especially chaotic moment under Trump, but the truth is that this is what always happens when the government fails to provide a service it has monopolized.

As Mises explained brilliantly in his book Bureaucracy, because government immunizes itself from economic losses, it cannot conduct economic calculation like everyone operating within a market does. By economic calculation, Mises meant the allocation of scarce resources towards whatever uses best meet the wants and needs of the end user, and the constant refinement and search for even more valuable ventures spurred on by the profit-and-loss incentive.

Government bureaucracies do not experience economic losses when they fail to provide adequate service. That alone effectively guarantees that government will frequently fail end users—not even just because officials face no immediate downsides for failing but because the mechanism that would let them know that they had failed is absent.

However, on top of that, when the government has effectively monopolized a service and therefore prevents anyone from coming in and offering consumers the service in its place, every single problem can be blamed on a lack of adequate spending.

Meaning, for the government, failure frequently results in a raise. And when the failures continue, they in turn are used to justify even more raises.

And that has been the defining feature of the FAA’s “modernization” of the nation’s air traffic control system.

Despite what Trump administration officials like Duffy want us to think, the effort to bring the country’s antiquated ATC infrastructure up to date isn’t new; it’s what the FAA has been promising to do for at least forty-five years.

In 1981, the FAA launched its National Airspace Systems plan, which, according to the Government Accountability Office (GAO), was supposed to overhaul the nation’s aging infrastructure in about ten years and cost around $12 billion. But two decades and $35 billion later, the FAA said it needed another $16 billion—bringing the total to $51 billion.

That year, 2003, Congress launched NextGen, which was supposed to be a fresh, joint modernization program between the FAA and airlines that was meant to be complete by 2025. But, by the end of 2024, the program had completed only 16 percent of its promised benefits, despite additional supplemental funding secured during the Obama and later Biden administrations. NextGen is now estimated to cost over $36 billion if it’s ever completed.

Then, in the spring of 2025, air traffic controllers at Newark Airport lost radar and radio contact with planes for about a minute and a half. That kicked off weeks of disruptions at that airport and led the Trump administration to announce yet another plan for a “brand new” air traffic control system. The “Big Beautiful Bill” gave the FAA $12.5 billion towards that end, and Duffy requested an additional $19 billion. Then a little over a year later, the FAA said the project would cost at least $10 billion more. Finally, last week, Duffy officially requested $30.1 billion, then changed that to $50 billion when the upgrade work caused a national ground stop.

That is a lot of numbers to keep track of, but the important thing to remember is that, throughout these forty-five years of “modernizing” the ATC, the money we’re told was required to complete it has kept going up. The asks went from $12 billion in 1981, to $51 billion by 2003, to another $36 billion for NextGen, with around $5 billion in supplemental modernization funding under Obama and Biden. Each new plan promised a modern air traffic control system within a decade or two, and none of them delivered it. And that is despite the fact that Congress has given the FAA over $100 billion in that same time period for these modernization efforts.

And now, the Trump administration’s big solution after last week’s national ground stop is to keep doing the exact same thing—throw more of our money at the problem and assume that, somehow, this time it’ll work.

It won’t work. Because the problems with America’s ATC system are not due to a lack of money. They are systemic problems grounded in the very nature of government bureaucracies.

If the Trump administration were truly serious about fixing air traffic control, it should shift its focus to eliminating the monopoly protections that have allowed the system’s many problems to persist.

image/svg+xml
Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.
What is the Mises Institute?

The Mises Institute is a non-profit organization that exists to promote teaching and research in the Austrian School of economics, individual freedom, honest history, and international peace, in the tradition of Ludwig von Mises and Murray N. Rothbard. 

Non-political, non-partisan, and non-PC, we advocate a radical shift in the intellectual climate, away from statism and toward a private property order. We believe that our foundational ideas are of permanent value, and oppose all efforts at compromise, sellout, and amalgamation of these ideas with fashionable political, cultural, and social doctrines inimical to their spirit.

Become a Member
Mises Institute