Grameen is a bust

Here is a chart from the JEL showing that the much-praised Grameen Bank is a highly subsidized, unprofitable, and unsustainable institution. I have a piece on this subject coming out tomorrow but I was just visiting with BK Marcus on the subject of why is it that so many otherwise libertarian writers were so quick to buy into the Nobel Prize rhetoric about how Grameen is using the magic of credit to the poor as a means of social uplift.

Why Wal-Mart Matters

The popular debate over Wal-Mart is an important part of a broader debate between freedom and interventionism, writes Art Carden. The company produces products people want to buy at low prices. It is better able to serve consumers. That is the source of its success. Those who vilify Wal-Mart do so not for Wal-Mart’s political failings but for Wal-Mart’s economic successes. The company’s critics are making inroads, but the anti-Wal-Mart campaign is a campaign to strangle a goose that has laid a disproportionate share of golden eggs.

Microcredit or Macrowelfare: The Myth of Grameen

Pundits left, right, and center appear to love the Nobel Prize winning bank and its founder, writes Jeffrey Tucker. The literature on Grameen is an echo chamber of hurrahs. Not even the Nobel Committee bother looking more deeply. Actually a closer look at this institution shows not a success but precisely the sort of flop you might expect from a government-subsidized program that is predicated on the view that money alone is the answer to poverty. What Bangladesh needs is not more personal indebtedness but radical economic reform.