Revisiting some problems with patents

I was recently talking with a very intelligent fellow patent attorney, and we got around to the subject of policy issues. One thing led to another and he discovered, and was a bit shocked by, myt opposition to patent and copyright. He was interested in some further information on the topics we discussed so I compiled an email with some information. As this corrals some useful links, material, and arguments about patents, I’ve provided an edited version below.

The Principled Case Against Patents

We should favor the government we have

John Derbyshire explains why he is tempted by Ron Paul’s views on government but must ultimately reject them. His argument seems to be that if government is small, it’s fine to favor small government. But if it is vast and imperial, we should favor that too. Doesn’t this reduce “conservatism” to nothing but status quo cheering of the state? I suppose that this has long been their esoteric doctrine, but it is amusing to see it stated so overtly.

Al Capone in Moscow

In the 30’s and 40’s when the world was young and naive, Freud and his fellow psychotherapists had legions of followers. Theories of human behavior flourished like mosquitos on Summer nights. If we could just find the causal factors, human behavior would be as predictable as the union of hydrogen and oxygen producing water.

One mainstream theory said the personality was structured by birth trauma — tough birth, tough individual. a psychiatrist — Otto Rank popularized this theory.