Study Guide to Human Action, Chapter XII

Chapter XII. The Sphere of Economic Calculation

Chapter Summary

1. The Character of Monetary Entries

Economic calculation encompasses everything that trades against money. Despite their apparent precision, most of the entries on balance sheets reflect the speculative anticipation of owners regarding future market conditions. Therefore, there is nothing “objective” about them. Even so, economic calculation is as effective as it could be.

Freedom in Baghdad

Here we get the news: “The Baghdad military command said Tuesday that unauthorized vehicles and motorcycles will be banned in the capital from 5 a.m. to midnight Wednesday. The vehicle ban is aimed at preventing violence on the fifth anniversary of the capture of Baghdad by U.S. troops about a month after the war started.... The boom of explosions could be heard across much of Baghdad, apparently coming from the neighborhood in eastern Baghdad. Low-flying jets circled the center of the capital several hours before sunrise.”

Oh Keynesian, Where Art Thou?

Almost everyone has something to say about the current crisis and the serious trouble our little greenback friend is in. We are about to be reminded that empires do not fall because of barbarians at the gates, wars of civilizations, or free trade. It’s the inflation that kills them. What is stunning about the current situation is the sudden disappearance from the stage of the not-so-long-ago fashionable Keynesian and monetarist doctrines.

Two Cents on the Penny

The price of the zinc required to mint pennies has been steadily increasing; the cost of producing a penny is now 1.7 cents — it costs nearly two pennies to make one. This has led many to question the continued existence of the penny and suggest it be abolished. Understanding negative seigniorage in economic terms will lead to an opposite conclusion: hundred dollar bills should be done away with.

Distinguishing Liberty from Slavery

At its heart, liberty means renouncing the use of coercion against others. That is why those who would employ coercion against others must invent arguments to defend their actions as consistent with liberty. That is also why slavery — the opposite of liberty — is a useful touchstone in evaluating defenses that coercion is consistent with liberty, when it always increases the enslavement of someone.

What If Public Schools Were Abolished?

There are decent public schools and terrible ones, so there is no use generalizing. Nor is there a need to trot out data on test scores. Let me just deal with economics. All studies have shown that average cost per pupil for public schools is twice that of private schools. if we could abolish public schools and compulsory schooling laws, and replace it all with market-provided education, we would have better schools at half the price, and be freer too. We would also be a more just society, with only the customers of education bearing the costs.

Great Search for the Mises Institute!

March was a record-breaking month for the Mises Institute and goodsearch.com. Your 1430 searches and $12.25 good shopping led to an all-time high monthly donation of $26.55. So far in less than two years your quick searches and shopping has resulted in $181.58 donated to the Mises Institute. Keep up the great work! Thank you. Postscript: To begin to good search for LVMI just type “mises” in the “Who do you goodsearch for?” field.