William Graham Sumner: Critic of Progressive Liberalism

In America today, as throughout the West, most people fundamentally accept the “welfare state.” Republican Presidents live happily with huge deficits in government accounts, while conservative politicians no longer challenge Medicare or Social Security. The State has become a pervasive force in every individual’s life, from cradle to grave; it consumes an ever- growing share of national product and employs a sizeable percentage of the labor force. Yet the “positive” state that so many now take for granted is a remarkably recent phenomenon.

Harman’s Moral Relativism

Moral relativism, a theory typically beclouded by inexact formulations and confusions with cultural relativism, has recently been defended lucidly and forcefully by Gilbert Harman. His article has the dual virtues of carefully stating the version of moral relativism being proposed and drawing explicit attention to the logical grounds underlying his advocacy. Indeed, Harman characterizes his relativism as “a soberly logical thesis,” and it is as such that it deserves analysis.

Volume 3, Number 3 (1979)

Nonexcludability and Government Financing of Public Goods

Many economists consider public goods to be a case of market “failure.” They argue that the free market cannot finance the optimal amount of public goods. Therefore, they say, the government must finance their provision. In this paper I shall challenge this view. Three well-known arguments supporting this view will be presented and critically examined.

Volume 3, Number 3 (1979)

The Radical Libertarian Tradition in Antislavery Thought

Volume 3, Number 3 (1979)

Slavery is a critical issue by which all libertarians may determine their bona fides. Slavery and liberty being polar opposites, there is no question that the libertarian must unconditionally oppose slavery and support liberty. However, there are several alternatives. First, the libertarian may advocate simple abolition, and no more. The means of production, the plantations on which the slaves had worked, would then remain in the hands of the masters.

The Development of Municipal Fire Departments in the United States

Volume 3, Number 3 (1979)

1. Introduction

In 1852 not one city in the United States paid its firemen; they were all volunteers. By 1880 most of the cities with more than 10,000 people—and many with fewer—had municipally paid fire departments, as did most cities in Europe. But until 1866 the fire department serving the city of London was neither volunteer nor municipally paid; it was privately owned and operated by the city’s fire insurance underwriters.

Entrepreneurial Activity and American Economic Progress

It is to some extent heartening to know that economists are once again concerned with entrepreneurship and its role in economic life. Lest one be over- whelmed with joy, though, it is useful to recall that economists have toyed with this subject before, and with little enough direct impact upon the central body of economic thought as it is propagated by text and lecture from one generation of economists to the next.

Conservation, “X-Inefficiency” and Efficient Use of Natural Resources

The early conservation movement in the United States was initiated by Theodore Roosevelt in 1908 when he called together a conference of state governors. The premise of the conservation movement, sometimes pointed to as Roosevelt’s most lasting achievement, was that natural resources are being used too rapidly and that political controls should be used to conserve the proper amount of resources for future generations.

Where They Stand: The Libertarian Party and Its Competition, 1968-1978

When analyzing election results, the Libertarian Party and other elements of the movement focus usually on the LP’s current political star in order to prove that the libertarian cause is advancing.Examples of this policy can be seen in the euphoria surrounding Hospers’ electoral vote in 1972; MacBride’s showing and the LP’s “Third Largest Party” status in 1976; and Ed Clark’s 377,960 votes for California Governor in 1978.

Volume 3, Number 4 (1979)