Discussion: Must we Choose between Chandran Kukathas’s “Two Constructions of Libertarianism”?

Volume 1, Article 22 (2009)

Introduction

Chandran Kukathas argues that we have a problem in how to understand Libertarianism, and that this problem requires us to choose between two views, each of which has uncomfortable implications. He begins by noting that “Libertarians believe that all individuals are entitled to live as they choose, free from interference by other persons or by the state. ...

Against Polanyi-centrism: Hayek and the Re-emergence of “Spontaneous Order”

Volume 8, No. 4 (Winter 2005)

F.A. Hayek is known for making a number of important contributions to economics and social thought. If, however, one had to identify a single concept that captures the thrust of Hayek’s intellectual project, one would probably have to say “spontaneous order.” The intellectual history of spontaneous order has largely been written according to one standard account. That account is, in a nutshell, as follows: The first major theorists of spontaneous order were the Scottish Enlightenment philosophers of the eighteenth century, especially Hume and Smith.