Value Investing’s Compatibility with Austrian Economics — Truth or Myth? A Rejoinder

Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics 20, no. 2 (Summer 2017)

ABSTRACT: In four ways, say Rapp, Olbrich and Venitz (2017), “the seeming compatibility between value investing and Austrian economics must be characterized as a myth.” I disagree. The authors’ major contention—namely that “value investing’s definition of value is fundamentally at odds with the Austrian value concept”—is demonstrably false.

Dr. Chris Leithner is managing director of Leithner & Company Pty.

The US Constitution Was Never Necessary for Military Defense

Before the US Constitution of 1787 was ratified, its proponents have claimed a centralized and powerful American state was necessary for the purposes of military defense.

But, as the Anti-Federalists of the time pointed out, the older constitution (known as the Articles of Confederation) had already been sufficient to allow the colonies to defeat what was the most powerful state on earth — the British Empire.

The Best Defense Is a Capitalist One

Political scientist John Mueller is not convinced that nuclear weapons are the driving force behind the lack of major wars in recent decades. His article “The Essential Irrelevance of Nuclear Weapons” in International Security (Fall 1988) offers a informative contrary view to the often-bland assertion that nuclear weapons — and not the highly destructive nature of conventional wars — are what keep world powers away from new wars. 

Entrepreneurship: Kirzner vs. Mises

[Originally appeared as “Professor Hébert on Entrepreneurship” in the Journal of Libertarian Studies 7, no. 2 (Fall, 1985): 281–86.]

​Since I admittedly know more about Austrian economic theory than about Richard Cantillon, I would like to focus my comments on the Austrian aspects of Professor Hébert’s paper, in particular his discussion of entrepreneurship. Hébert is correct in his discussion of the differences between Mises’s and Kirzner’s concept of the entrepreneur and in his critique of the Kirzner approach.