Mises Wire

Economic Harmony and Disharmony

Mises Wire Gary Galles

Government now routinely embraces massive amounts of mud- and blame-slinging as standard operating procedure. The “other guys” are always extremists who exhibit unprincipled intransigence, which prevents agreement on self-defined white hats’ solutions. It illustrates that the government we suffer from is not a means to expanding harmony, but the greatest cause of our disharmony.

Continually leveraging government power into more areas where people’s views dramatically differ expands how frequently some people’s preferences are forced on others. That guarantees acrimony, not harmony.

Perhaps the most insightful understanding of government’s influence on social accord comes from Frederic Bastiat, among history’s ablest defenders of freedom, in Economic Harmonies. On his birthday, with Washington’s control of Americans’ lives metastasizing, his contributions there merit consideration.

All men’s impulses, when motivated by legitimate self-interest, fall into a harmonious social patternthe practical solution…is simply not to thwart those interests or to try to redirect them.

Coercion…[has] never yet done anything…except to eliminate liberty.

Where do you…establish the acting principle of coercion?...if you entrust men with arbitrary power, you must first prove that…their minds will be exempt from error, their hands from greed, and their hearts from covetousness.

[But] It is not necessary to force into harmony things that are inherently harmonious.

Let men labor, exchange, learn, band together, act, and react upon one another…there can result from their free and intelligent activity only order, harmony and progress…

The question is whether or not we have liberty...not profoundly disrupted by the contrary act of institutions of human origin.

Social order, freed from its abuses and the obstacles that have been put in its way…[is] the most admirable, the most complete, the most lasting, the most universal, and the most equitable of all associations…

The laws of Providence are harmonious…only when they operate under conditions of freedom…Therefore when we perceive something inharmonious in the world, it cannot fail to correspond to some lack of freedom or justice.

The state always acts through the instrumentality of force…What are the things that men have the right to impose on one another by force?...I have no right to force anyone to be religious, charitable, well educated, or industrious; but I have the right to force him to be just: this is a case of legitimate self-defense.

If, therefore, the use of force by the individual is justified solely on grounds of legitimate self-defense, we need only recognize that government action always takes the form of force to conclude that by its very nature it can be exerted solely for the maintenance of order, security, and justice. All government action beyond this limit is an encroachment upon the individual’s conscience, intelligence, and industry—in a word, upon human liberty.

Accordingly, we must [turn]…to the task of freeing the whole domain of private activity from the encroachments of government.

Restrict the public police force to its one and only rightful function…from what source could come all our present ills…which teach the people to look to the government for everything…to the ever increasing and unnatural meddling of politics into all things…

Many causes of disturbances, friction, disaffection, envy, and disorder would no longer exist…it reduces evil to the smaller and smaller area left open to it by the ignorance and perversity of our human frailty, which it is the function of harmony to prevent or chastise.

            Bastiat’s Economic Harmonies identified individual rights and freedom as central to social harmony and progress. But such freedom required government “exerted solely for the maintenance of order, security, and justice.” Every expansion beyond that narrow bound, in which government acts as ubiquitous dispenser of goodies and garnishments, inherently destroys the harmony that self-ownership and solely voluntary associations could provide us. The economic disharmony of coercion destroys the economic harmony of freedom. 

All Rights Reserved ©
Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.
Support Liberty

The Mises Institute exists solely on voluntary contributions from readers like you. Support our students and faculty in their work for Austrian economics, freedom, and peace.

Donate today
Group photo of Mises staff and fellows