Mises Daily Articles
The Scana Scam
The Scana Corporation is a government-created monopoly that provides electricity to most of the state of
Scana recently ordered its employees to remove Confederate flag bumper stickers from their cars if they are parked in company parking lots, and it prohibited employees from parking company vehicles in the parking lot of
The president pro tem of the
This is a good idea as far as it goes. But if Scana is plundering and stealing from the citizens of
There is no reason why Scana--or any other utility--should be given a government grant of monopoly, other than that the politicians who give such grants like to receive "campaign contributions" and other forms of kickbacks funded by the monopoly profits created by the monopoly franchises. The notion that electric power is a "natural monopoly" is a myth (see my article, "The Myth of Natural Monopoly," Review of Austrian Economics, vol. 9, No. 2, 1996).
According to this myth, the nature of the industry (high fixed costs) would, in a free market, lead to one giant company becoming a monopoly. Therefore, according to the myth, government should not wait for this to happen but should create a monopoly and regulate the price so that consumers can benefit from economies of scale and lower prices.
This theory is completely ahistorical. In the late nineteenth century, American cities typically had a half dozen or more electric companies competing for business. Economist Harold Demsetz pointed out in his 1989 book, Efficiency, Competition, and Policy, that in 1887, six electric light companies were organized in New York City; 45 companies competed in Chicago by 1907; and Duluth, Minnesota, was served by five competing companies. The same was true for the natural gas industry.
These companies attempted to create cartels, but since all cartels are notoriously unstable, they decided that the only way to have a monopoly was to get the government to use its coercive powers to prevent competition. On the free market, this could never be achieved. They succeeded in doing so, and most Americans have been victimized by government-sponsored electric power cartels ever since.
Not all state and local governments have conspired with electric utility executives to fleece their citizens, however. In his 1986 book, Direct Utility Competition: The Natural Monopoly Myth,
These rival companies competed vigorously through prices and services, unlike in the monopoly states such as
If Senator McConnell wanted to take the moral high ground in his spat with the Scana Corporation, he would do all he could to deregulate the electric power and natural gas industry in South Carolina regardless of what Scana's stand is on the Confederate flag--or on any other public policy issue, for that matter.