Mises Daily

Home | Library | FDR: Wrecker

FDR: Wrecker

December 3, 1998

Tags BiographiesBig GovernmentWar and Foreign Policy

The Roosevelt Myth by John T. Flynn is the best book ever written on the New
Deal, the drive to war, and the terrible consequences of the FDR presidency. A new
edition of the book, with a brilliant introduction by Ralph Raico, is now
available for $25 (hardback) on mises.org.

See The Roosevelt Myth

The Investors Business Daily (Dec 3, 1998) ran the following
outstanding editorial on the the book's 50th anniversary edition:

Revising Roosevelt

Franklin D. Roosevelt saved America from the Great Depression, right? Not
exactly. In fact, the Depression raged on through FDR's 12 years in office.
The Depression really didn't end until World War II.

You'd never know that from reading most history books. But there are some
exceptions. One is John T. Flynn's ''The Roosevelt Myth,'' which has just
been reissued in a 50th-anniversary edition.

Flynn's book is a careful account of Roosevelt's presidency.

Flynn was no businessman, no Republican shill. He was a respected, old- line
liberal journalist who made his name with a series of books attacking big

That's what makes his indictment of Roosevelt all the more notable.

He paints FDR as an intellectual lightweight who was guided by no real
principles, just a lust for power. Roosevelt was a charismatic man who was
loved by the American people, but he never earned the trust of his Democrat
allies, Flynn argues.

Roosevelt, Flynn reminds us, campaigned as something of a conservative when
he first ran for president in '32.

He attacked Herbert Hoover for running deficits and piling up the national

''The New Deal would abolish useless bureaus, reduce salaries, cut federal
expenditures 25 percent,'' Flynn wrote of FDR's promises on the hustings.

Instead, when he took office, FDR started running up spending and the
deficit. Within 100 days, he had piled up a deficit larger than Hoover had
produced in two years.

And Roosevelt always used that spending to his advantage.

Citing Congressional investigations, Flynn documented how FDR's loyalists
controlled Works Progress Administration jobs. Those working on WPA projects
were sometimes spied on, Flynn's research showed.

WPA workers who were Republicans were explicitly told they had to switch
their registration to Democrat to keep their jobs. And Democrats were told
whom to support in the primaries if they wanted to stay at their jobs.

By his death, FDR had spent more than all U.S. presidents before him
combined, Flynn noted.

FDR had campaigned on a smaller government platform. But the first New Deal
that he delivered to Congress was something else.

Under the National Recovery Administration, Roosevelt tried to bring all
major industries together into cartels.

These cartels, under government guidance, would set production, prices and
wages in each industry. Those who violated those rules were prosecuted.

For instance, Jack Magid, a New Jersey tailor, was jailed for pressing a
suit for 35 cents when the NRA had fixed the price at 40 cents.

The NRA was explicitly modeled on what Benito Mussolini had done in Italy.
Flynn didn't endear himself to many by daring to call FDR's policies

Fortunately, the Supreme Court struck down the NRA. So FDR came back with a
second and third New Deal. Each increased federal taxes, spending and

But none really ended the Depression. The economy grew in fits and starts
during the '30s. But unemployment remained at double-digit rates, and the
brief growth spurts always stalled out.

By '38, there were more people unemployed than when FDR was elected six
years earlier.

Unemployment only fell back to pre-Depression levels after roughly one-fifth
of the work force was drafted to fight World War II.

Roosevelt never had much of a clue what caused the Depression, Flynn noted.He just thought that somehow business had been responsible, and he thought
it his task to punish business for its sins.

And when the Depression didn't end, FDR blamed business opposition to his

At times, FDR talked as if business was somehow deliberately putting off a
recovery until he had left office so that he wouldn't get the credit for his
good deeds.

More likely, the high taxes on income and capital gains that FDR pushed
through Congress and the red tape he set up sapped the American economy of
any strength it had left.


(C) Copyright 1998 Investors Business Daily, Inc.

Also, read Robert Higg's article on why we need no more "great presidents".

Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.

Follow Mises Institute