The Mises Community
An online community for fans of Austrian economics and libertarianism, featuring forums, user blogs, and more.

Comments: Myths about libertarianism

Page Details

First published by:
ama gi
on Thu, Sep 25 2008
Last revision by:
nazgulnarsil
on Wed, Mar 11 2009
10 people found this article useful.

Myths about libertarianism

Sort by: Published Date | Most Recent | Most Useful
1 2 Next >
By: nhaag Posted on Wed, Oct 22 2008 4:09 AM

I do not like the remark about paranoid consipracist. Especially the fact that so called "9/11 truthers" are put into the same category as UFO believers.

This should be rewritten, because to raise serious questions about the events of, and surrounding, 9/11 is certainly not a paranoid conspiracy (whatever that means anyway).

I wouldn't want to even make a link between personal believes, be it UFOS, NEw World Order, the rebirth of Donald Duck or any other Idea, with libertarianism. It just has nothing to do with it. Like the sort of icecream you prefer doesn't show anything about your philosophical foundation as well.

Else, a great start

Cheers

By: ama gi Posted on Wed, Oct 22 2008 7:38 PM

<i>I wouldn't want to even make a link between personal believes, be it UFOS, NEw World Order, the rebirth of Donald Duck or any other Idea, with libertarianism. It just has nothing to do with it. Like the sort of icecream you prefer doesn't show anything about your philosophical foundation as well.</i>

Exactly.  What I am trying to do is sever that "link" in people's minds.

By: exile Posted on Wed, Nov 5 2008 3:47 PM

To both, I took it to mean "Joe the Plumber" would group 9/11 truthers, UFO conspiracy theorists, and libertarians in the same category. This article should seek to separate 9/11 truthers and UFO conspiracy theorists from libertarians, regardless of whether grouping 9/11 truthers and conspiracy theorists together is an apt grouping or not.

By: ama gi Posted on Thu, Nov 6 2008 9:23 PM

You made a pretty nice contribution, exile.  good job!

By: exile Posted on Fri, Nov 7 2008 2:37 PM

Thanks Ama gi, I have seen these same arguments used online before too and I think it would be useful to give people a firm understanding of how to respond to those accusations. However, I don't understand why you reverted my 9/11/UFO conspiracy edits I made a while ago? The myth says:

"Libertarians are paranoid lunatics whose political ideologies are motivated by a bizarre and unfounded fear of government."

I wanted to tweak that paragraph to explain that the fear/distrust of government is not unfounded (like some conspiracy theorists are), but rather is derived straight from political philosophy (ie. we distrust government BECAUSE we believe government cannot inherently be trusted no matter how good or bad they try to be). The change you made makes the sentence simply say "we distrust government and that's not crazy" which I don't think would help dispel any myths. I recommend reverting back, but wanted to ask you first in case there was another goal here.

Ludwig von Mises Institute | 518 West Magnolia Avenue | Auburn, Alabama 36832-4528

Phone: 334.321.2100 · Fax: 334.321.2119

contact@Mises.org | webmaster | AOL-IM MainMises

Mises.org sitemap