I was reading about a 1948 United States Supreme Court case that did not allow state courts to enforce race based restrictive covenants against willing sellers (white) and willing buyers (black). The other members whose properties were also under the restrictive convenant used state courts to submit an injunction against the sale.
The Supreme Court said that these racially restrictive covenants could be voluntarily followed but if there is a willing buyer and willing seller the courts would view the contract as unenforceable due to a violation of the fourteenth amendment since the enforcement of the covenant relied not on the willingness of the owner selling the property but exclusively on the state courts.
Many libertarians have a problem with that ruling and not just on the gounds of federalism. But As I was thinking about it how is this decision to make this contract unenforceable any different from the older common law doctrine of not enforcing agreements in restraint of trade that predated the modern silliness of Antitrust law? Under that rule people could voluntarily agree to industry wide price hikes but that did not last since the courts would not enforce the agreements against people that failed to follow it and who got more market share from the cheaper prices.
Also to my knowledge Restrictive covnenats are usually meant to govern the use of the land not who owns it. For instance to make sure that no commercial buildings are built in a residential area but unlike zoning law it is done by private agreement.
The really scarry part of those court decisions was and is the implication that all contracts are ultimately enforceable by the courts, which is part of the state. In other words, no contracts are really private matters. Since all contracts are public matters, the state can reshape them to whatever is prevailing public policy.
Ludwig von Mises Institute | 518 West Magnolia Avenue | Auburn, Alabama 36832-4528
Phone: 334.321.2100 · Fax: 334.321.2119
contact@Mises.org | webmaster | AOL-IM MainMises
Mises.org sitemap