The Mises Community
An online community for fans of Austrian economics and libertarianism, featuring forums, user blogs, and more.

Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

Latest post Mon, May 12 2008 12:34 AM by Geoffrey Allan Plauche. 8 replies.
  • Thu, May 8 2008 11:03 AM

    • Fred Furash
    • Top 25 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on Tue, Jan 15 2008
    • Belgium
    • Posts 295
    • Points 5,290

    Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VIs5r3ujBmw

    That seemed pretty convincing to me, after thinking it over a while.

    What do you guys think? This is probably a good video to watch for minarchists too Wink

    "What we do in life, echoes in eternity."

    • Post Points: 65
  • Thu, May 8 2008 11:18 AM In reply to

    Re: Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

    I don't think it's the Darwin Theory he thought he found.  The politics of special interests is a closed system with alot less variables than civil society.  If you're going to say A works in X and therefore A works in Y, you need to show a strong similarity between X and Y, and I don't think special interests mimics real society close enough to draw strong proof .

    Communism/socialism seems to work in small communities like Kibbutzim but we know that it's actually a horrible system.

     

    • Post Points: 20
  • Thu, May 8 2008 11:25 AM In reply to

    • Fred Furash
    • Top 25 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on Tue, Jan 15 2008
    • Belgium
    • Posts 295
    • Points 5,290

    Re: Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

    I'd say socialism works in small communities because there is little complexity. Without division of labour, in small communities it becomes fairly easy to manage things, although the fact that there is some governing body will prevent any real growth, and people doom themselves to low standards of living.

    In terms of special interests and government corruption though, things are far more complex than a simple farm community. The sheer amount of different lobbyists representing varying special interests, all going against each other at one moment, and then spontaneously organising coalitions the next - this is something you could equate with dvision of labour and specialisation, perhaps? It seems fairly akin to the market economy (including concepts such as opportunity costs in dealing with one special interest instead of another due to limited funding).

    "What we do in life, echoes in eternity."

    • Post Points: 5
  • Thu, May 8 2008 11:45 AM In reply to

    Re: Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

    Fred Furash:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VIs5r3ujBmw

    That seemed pretty convincing to me, after thinking it over a while.

    What do you guys think? This is probably a good video to watch for minarchists too Wink

    This isn't really new. See the following predecessors:

    Alfred Cuzan, "Do We Ever Really Get Out of Anarchy?"

    James Ostrowski, "The Myth of Democratic Peace: Why Democracy Cannot Deliver Peace in the 21st Century"

    Geoffrey Allan Plauche, "On the Social Contract and the Persistence of Anarchy" (Synthesizes and extends the previous two.)

     

    Yours in liberty,
    Geoffrey Allan Plauche
    Doctoral Candidate
    Political Science
    Louisiana State University

    "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?"
    (Who watches the watchmen?)
    -Juvenal, Satires VI.347

    • Post Points: 5
  • Thu, May 8 2008 12:17 PM In reply to

    • maxpot46
    • Top 50 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on Wed, Apr 9 2008
    • Brooklyn, NY
    • Posts 186
    • Points 3,210

    Re: Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

    I feel like I just wasted 20 min of my life.  This guy is a pretty good speaker, so it was pleasant, but the "payoff" sucked.  "Anarchy works almost perfectly when done within the state, so it'll work even better without the state?"  This is completely unconvincing and useless, and it sure didn't require 20 min to present.  Very disrespectful of my time, IMO.  Cut it down to 1 min and maybe it'd get more than 400 views.

     

    "He that struggles with us strengthens our nerves, and sharpens our skill. Our antagonist is our helper." Edmund Burke

    • Post Points: 20
  • Thu, May 8 2008 3:39 PM In reply to

    • Juan
    • Top 10 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on Sat, Oct 20 2007
    • Rosario - Argentina
    • Posts 654
    • Points 12,030

    Re: Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

    Molyneaux has 'discovered' that governments are voluntary associations. Of course they are. Anybody can join the mafia. But from the fact that membership in a criminal gang is voluntary it does not follow that a free society is possible.

    I'm not sure I see why his argument would convince statists that they are wrong.
    • Post Points: 5
  • Sun, May 11 2008 10:55 PM In reply to

    • shazam
    • Top 75 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on Sun, Feb 24 2008
    • Orange County, CA
    • Posts 110
    • Points 2,070

    Re: Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

     His argument doesn't make sense, though. Isn't the entire idea of anarchism based on that the state cannot work, since it is a coercive monopoly? Using that argument, it means that since this non-contractual anarchism doesn't work, individualist anarchism wouldn't work either, and that means that no political system could work. I would say that he has opened up a paradox here.

    Anarcho-capitalism boogeyman

    • Post Points: 20
  • Mon, May 12 2008 12:07 AM In reply to

    • Nitroadict
    • Top 25 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on Mon, Jan 7 2008
    • Bored & Extremely Dangerous
    • Posts 372
    • Points 6,090

    Re: Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

    I didn't watch the video, but if that's what a huge revelation is, I would vote that this video puts him at risk of jumping the shark.  I thought voluntaryism was in Anarchism 101 ?

    • Post Points: 20
  • Mon, May 12 2008 12:34 AM In reply to

    Re: Stef comes up with a proof of anarchy in existence...

    Nitroadict:

    I didn't watch the video, but if that's what a huge revelation is, I would vote that this video puts him at risk of jumping the shark.  I thought voluntaryism was in Anarchism 101 ?

    His alleged innovation is the idea that state's are internally anarchic, i.e., the branches of government are in an anarchic relationship with each other. He may or may not have developed the idea independently, but the idea is not new (see my first post above). Also, the idea that the international system of states is anarchic is very far from new; it's been understood by international relations scholars (my second doctoral examination field is IR) for a very long time.

     

    Yours in liberty,
    Geoffrey Allan Plauche
    Doctoral Candidate
    Political Science
    Louisiana State University

    "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?"
    (Who watches the watchmen?)
    -Juvenal, Satires VI.347

    • Post Points: 5
Page 1 of 1 (9 items) | RSS

Ludwig von Mises Institute | 518 West Magnolia Avenue | Auburn, Alabama 36832-4528

Phone: 334.321.2100 · Fax: 334.321.2119

contact@Mises.org | webmaster | AOL-IM MainMises

Mises.org sitemap